Truly living
-
Thinking is preparation. Living is transformation — Concepts, plans, and insights are essential, but they never meant to be where the work stopped.
Intellectualizing can become its own hiding place — When the effort to understand becomes a substitute for the courage to act, we can spend years in the vicinity of change without ever truly living it.
Real change happens in the doing — The version of you that you are reaching for is met most fully in the embodied, ordinary moments of a life being actually lived, not merely thought about.
-
The words "content creator" may make you roll your eyes. But in Part 1 of our series, Kickstarter co-founder Yancey Strickler explains how the creator economy is changing work, art and what we value.
Click here to listen to the episode from TED Radio Hour!
The space between knowing and living
Have you ever felt that there was a particular quality of life that is often thought about more than it is lived? Consider the plans that never get started, the insights that are collected but not applied, or even the understandings that we hold with sincerity that somehow never translate into different behavior.
Maybe you have been there or maybe you are now — you’ve read the books, taken the courses, listened to the podcasts, articulated the plan, and yet what you can understand conceptually does not actually show up in your life as identifiable change.
Instead of labelling this as evidence of a failure, we can take a look at what it truly is — the human tendency to mistake insight for change. Today, we will explore the experiences we have thought our ways through, when they might have been meant to be lived out. We’ll bring our attention to the ways that intellectualizing can become its own form of avoidance, and consider what becomes possible when we transition from concept to experience.
The Finger and The Moon
Prior to contemporary psychology describing the limits of the conceptual mind, contemplative traditions were pointing to the same recognition with striking clarity.
There is a notable teaching from Zen Buddhism that describes the relationship between concepts and reality. The teacher points at the moon, and the student, rather than looking at the moon, becomes fascinated by the finger doing the pointing. The teaching is a gentle reminder that concepts, no matter how clear, are not the thing they are describing. They can guide us toward direct experience, but they are not a substitute for it. Mistaking the finger for the moon is a common and costly error of the thinking mind.
Similarly:
Falling in love feels different from understanding love as a concept
Concepting grief and living it are very different
The map of a territory varies from the experience of navigating that territory
Thinking has its value, and also its limits. When we mistake the concept for the thing itself, we can become so absorbed in the elegance of our understanding that we forget that the understanding was only ever meant to point us toward a lived experience of real life. The reality is always larger than what can be said about it.
The version of ourselves we are becoming will not be reached through better maps, but rather through walking the terrain of our actual lives, in the messy, embodied, and unpredictable way that they unfold.
Is intellectualizing your hiding place?
Let’s explore what occurs when the mind stays in the conceptual. In psychodynamic theory, there is a defense mechanism known as intellectualization. This is the tendency to engage a situation cognitively, through reasoning, analysis, and abstract understanding — in a way that keeps us at a safe emotional distance from what is actually happening. This is engagement, but at a level that stays above the felt, embodied, vulnerable experience of a situation. Doing such, we effectively avoid the part of the work that would actually change us while appearing to do something beneficial.
A potentially more related, and common experience, is analysis paralysis. This is a state in which we generate so many considerations, options, and possible interpretations that we become unable to act. Analysis paralysis often masquerades as thoughtfulness or care, but beneath it functions as a way of not choosing, not moving, not risking the messiness of a real decision met with real action.
As a therapist, one of the observations I hold is that therapy, when a person is not yet ready to translate insight into action, can quietly become another version of intellectualization. This is not a judgment, as insight gathering is often a necessary phase of the process, but when insights are not followed by embodied action within our waking day to day lives, we find ourselves in yet another resting place — a place where we feel productive about our growth without actually growing at all. This is not just a recognition that exists in therapy but in various personal development spaces, spiritual communities, and professional coaching. Deeply understanding a problem is valuable to formulating a solution, but the understanding is not a solution in and of itself.
Maybe you recognize this in your own life as:
A goal that you understand and have conceptualized clearly but have made no real progress on
A pattern you can articulate with clarity but have not yet begun to change
A decision that has been analyzed for so long that the analysis itself has become the substitute for action
Off The Page: Actioning The Insights
Being with experience
Your practice this week
Direct experience of change is often less elegant than the concept of change. It is messier, slower, and more humbling. It is also where the actual transformation we desire happens.
Your relationships are not changed by understanding its dynamics, but by having an honest conversation
The habit is built not by planning it out, but by actually doing it
Healing is not integrated by naming it, but by living into a new pattern of being with ourselves
The vision is not realized by imagining it, but by taking small steps in its direction — then another and another
The conceptual mind will always have a role. It helps us to prepare, discern, and reflect. But it’s highest function is to serve the living, not to replace it. When we begin to identify with the person who is doing rather than the person who is analyzing, we begin to recognize what is possible for us as people. Take a look at the reflection questions and strategies this week and notate what insights show up for you.
Reflection Questions:
Where in your life have you been thinking more than living?
What insight have you been holding for a long time without having translated it into action?
Where has intellectualizing become your hiding place?
Strategies:
Choose one thing you already understand, and do it
Identify an insight that you have been holding without applying it. This could be a boundary you know you need to set, a habit you know would serve you, or a conversation that needs to be had. Take one action based on what you already know.
Replace one moment of analysis with one moment of experience
When you catch yourself analyzing a situation for the fourth or fifth time this week, pause and ask, “What could I do, right now, that would move this forward?” Do that thing and keep it as simple as possible. Create a step in your intended direction.
Let the doing teach you
As you take space for practice this week, resist the urge to analyze how it went. Instead, just sit with the felt experience of having done the thing, whatever your thing is. Notice what shifted in your body. Notice anything that feels more available to you. This is embodied learning and can be experimented with each time you move from thinking to doing in small and large ways in your life.
The version of yourself that you are seeking out does not live in the concept of change, but rather in the direct and imperfect experience of life being lived with courage.
Thank You
Thank you for joining me this week! I’m excited to keep sharing insights from my work, research, and personal journey with you.
Did something resonate with you? Curious about applying these strategies in your life? Or know someone who might benefit?
Use the link below to schedule a consultation or send this newsletter to a friend!
Extras
Let your voice be heard
Click the button below to share anonymous feedback on Mindful Monday. This will support me in continually bringing aligned insights that you all can action in your day to day life to witness a shift.
● New Reads in The Library
Currently me and my book club are reading, “Dopamine Nation” by Anna Lembke, MD — click the link below to add this to your library and read along with us!
A Listen for the Week
As I continue to consume relevant content, I will share it here to deepen knowledge, perspective, and inquiry on a variety of topics related to wellness. This week I am sharing an episode from the TED Radio Hour podcast.
The Price of Creativity
“The words “content creator” may make you roll your eyes. But in Part 1 of our series, Kickstarter co-founder Yancey Strickler explains how the creator economy is changing work, art, and what we value.”
Follow me on instagram
Explore the Shop
Passionate about wellness? I am currently partnered with two brands that focus on the creation of products to support individual wellness. Navigate the links below to learn more!
Power of Your Purchase — For qualifying purchases, a portion of the proceeds are donated to organizations focused on supporting mental health. Click here to learn more.
Soothing, slightly weighted, pre-shrunk materials that provide comfort and calm as you take on your everyday.
● Ads
Read More
